Why We Think Others Are More Influenced: The Third-Person Effect Explained

The Biased Brain Podcast with Owen Hawthorne

Explore the intriguing world of cognitive biases and human cognition in this engaging podcast. Discover how bias in decision making shapes our perceptions and influences our choices. Join us as we delve into the science behind critical thinking and biases, providing practical insights to enhance your understanding and control over your thought processes. Whether you're a psychology student or curious observer, this podcast offers valuable tools to help you unveil the hidden biases in your mind.

Understanding the Third-Person Effect: Why We Think Others Are More Influenced Than Us

Have you ever noticed that when a new controversial ad or a viral social media post pops up, most people tend to say, "That stuff might mess with other people’s heads, but I’m not affected at all"? Well, that’s not just casual skepticism — it’s actually a well-documented psychological phenomenon called the Third-Person Effect.

Let me explain it like this: the Third-Person Effect is basically our mind’s way of convincing us that other people are more likely to be impacted or swayed by certain messages than we are ourselves. It’s kind of like thinking, “Sure, that political ad might trick my neighbors, but I see right through it.” Sounds familiar, right?

This effect was first studied in the 1980s and it’s been pretty influential in understanding not just how people perceive media, but also how they assume influence and bias work in society. The cool thing about it is that it highlights a major quirk in our human cognition: we think we’re less susceptible to persuasion or manipulation compared to others. But guess what? Our brains are just as “biased” as anyone else’s.

So why does this happen? It’s partly because of something deeply rooted in our psychology called “self-serving bias.” We want to see ourselves as smart, in control, and less gullible. It’s like giving our own brain a little pat on the back for being sharper than the “average person.” But this isn’t just about feeling good — it has real consequences.

For example, when people believe that others are more affected by harmful content — like fake news, propaganda, or misleading ads — they often support stricter media regulation or censorship. They might think, “I’m fine with this message; it’s harmless to me, but it’s dangerous to someone else.” This means the Third-Person Effect can influence public opinion and policy, even though the perception is biased.

Now, this fits perfectly into the broader context of understanding cognitive biases and how our biased brain navigates everyday information. It is one of many illusions that keeps us from fully grasping just how susceptible we are to influence. Understanding these biases isn't just academic — it’s crucial for strengthening critical thinking and biases in decision making.

What’s even more interesting is that the effect varies based on what type of message we’re talking about. When the communication is seen as socially undesirable or harmful, the Third-Person Effect tends to be stronger. But if the message is positive or desirable, sometimes we actually think it influences us more than others — that’s called the “first-person effect.”

All this leads us back to the bigger picture of bias in decision making. We need to be aware that our perceptions of others — and ourselves — are tinted through a lens of bias and self-protection. Recognizing this is a big step toward becoming less naïve about how vulnerable our minds are.

If you’re curious to get a clearer picture of how these mental quirks work, a fantastic resource I highly recommend is the book, The Biased Brain by Bo Bennett, PhD. It breaks down complex ideas about our cognitive biases and the ways we can try to compensate for them in our daily lives. It’s great for anyone interested in human cognition and improving personal and societal decision making.

Explore the book and unravel the secrets of your mind today! Whether you want to boost your critical thinking or just understand why your brain sometimes plays tricks on you, this book is a smart place to start.

So, next time you catch yourself thinking “other people are the ones falling for fake news or manipulation,” remember the Third-Person Effect is at play. It’s a reminder that we’re all navigating a biased brain — and the more we recognize that, the better equipped we are to make wiser decisions and think critically.

Mitigate the Effects of Cognitive Biases and Become More Reasonable Register for the Online Course and Engage in Passive "Micro-learning" link Enroll Today